13 reasons why 2 people died
- 13 reasons why 2 people died serial#
- 13 reasons why 2 people died trial#
- 13 reasons why 2 people died tv#
Her narration - ostensibly her statement to the police - is riddled with one-liners that are supposed to come off as wise epigrams but are really just obvious bullshit. There is no real reason for her to care about Clay’s group of friends and no reason for them to care about her, let alone confide in her as much as they do. And those problems really are treated more or less interchangeably: as secrets each character hides until their showcase episode arrives, only to reveal the truth in a tear-streaked monologue that leaves Clay staring, mouth agape, at how little he understands the pain of his friends.Īni, meanwhile, is less a character than she is an exposition machine. It’s just endless, endless gray-toned scenes of sad teenagers whispering exposition tensely at each other before curling up to weep over their heroin addiction/steroid problem/deported parents/lost college scholarship/insert-extremely-topical-teen-problem here. That could be fun!īut god does this season drag. It’s a murder mystery where maybe you could root for the murderer, Murder on the Orient Express-style. Everyone in the main cast does have good reason to hate Bryce and want him to be dead. Theoretically, you can see how this story would be interesting. “I see things,” she tells us portentously in voiceover, before proceeding to lead us through the whole season to find out who murdered Bryce.
The whole thing is narrated by new student Ani ( Grace Saif), who is inexplicably best friends with the whole cast now but was also close with Bryce, because her mom is his grandfather’s live-in nurse, so Ani and Bryce also lived together. Now, Clay is a suspect for Bryce’s death, and to prove his own innocence, he has to find the real killer.
13 reasons why 2 people died serial#
Bryce was a serial rapist who casually ruined lives, so most of the main cast had a reason to want him dead - including our hero, Clay ( Dylan Minnette), who nursed a crush on Hannah back when she was alive. Hannah’s rapist, the charming rich sociopath Bryce Walker ( Justin Prentice), is dead. Season three of 13 Reasons Why is a murder mystery. Vox-mark vox-mark vox-mark vox-mark vox-mark Season 3 is boring and also ridiculous He dead. It makes clumsy, lazy, unforced errors in exactly the moments that it’s striving for honesty, and if this time those errors might not lead to deaths, well, that’s a pretty low bar to aim for.Īdditionally, season three of 13 Reasons Why is a bad season of television. But it continues the approach that made season one so dangerous: This show insists on exploring very serious real-life problems in as much didactic detail as possible, but it does not show any evidence of having done the research to get the exploration right. Season three of 13 Reasons Why probably is less controversial than season one, in that it is probably not going to be linked to the deaths of any children. Then, earlier this year, the show backtracked long enough to remove that graphic suicide scene from season one, and to promise that season three would be much less controversial.
13 reasons why 2 people died trial#
It dropped a cheap and tawdry second season in 2018 that focused on the trial of Hannah’s rapist, and seemed to double down on all of the issues for which the first season was criticized - it ends with a graphic rape scene and an attempted school shooting - all the while maintaining both on and offscreen that really, it was just laying out some hard truths and exploring the real issues that teenagers face in their everyday lives. Nevertheless, 13 Reasons Why did keep going. That’s where the Jay Asher book the first season is based on ended as well. And the end of the season, in which the last tape is finally played and Hannah’s rapist is arrested, is clearly the natural ending point for the series.
It was easy to care for Hannah, easy to get wrapped up in the casually brutal teenage games her classmates played with her, and easy to want to know what led to her death. While at times the show could feel self-congratulatory in its grimness, it was addictive and thriller-like in its pacing. Season one of 13 Reasons Why told the story of doomed Hannah Baker ( Katherine Langford), a 16-year-old girl who has died by suicide, leaving behind a set of 13 cassette tapes for the 13 classmates she blamed for her death. It had critical acclaim back then for a reason.
13 reasons why 2 people died tv#
But if we put those extremely serious issues aside and look at it purely as entertainment, 13 Reasons Why season one was a solid TV show. The show’s first season was socially irresponsible in its depiction of suicide experts at the time warned that it violated most of their guidelines for avoiding suicide contagion, and a recent study found a correlation between the show’s 2017 premiere and an increase in youth suicide rates. In its 13-episode third season, Netflix’s 13 Reasons Why has proved definitively that it has no reason left to exist.